Residents Protest Development

A petition with 634 signatures of Ada County residents and other interested parties protesting a 1,500 home development overlooking the Boise River and Lucky Peak was filed Thursday with the Ada County Commission.

Anthony Jones, founder of something he calls delivered the petition to the Courthouse in a move to get the Commissioners to reject the pending rezone application for a development known as Hammer Flats.

Jones said in a press release the 700 acre plateau five miles east of Boise is home to at least 12,000 deer–the largest herd in the state– as well as elk, antelope, eagles and a hundred more species of wildlife. The proposed housing development adjoins the Idaho Fish and Game Department Wildlife Management Area.

The resumption of construction in the Harris Ranch subdivision combined with the proposed Hammer Flat development could pretty much eliminate winter forage areas for deer and elk, according to Jones.

Here is the measured response from Idaho Fish and Game:

By Al Van Vooren, Regional Supervisor
Idaho Department of Fish and Game – Southwest Region

Pulitzer-prize winning author Wallace Stegner once wrote of what he called one of the biggest fallacies imparted to the American West: development equals progress, progress is good, so therefore development is always good.

Recently released 2000 to 2004 growth statistics for Treasure Valley communities (where populations grew in size from between 43 and 76 percent) attest to the fact that Southwest Idaho has gained a reputation as a place to live and do business. High on the list of things that attract people to this locale are quality outdoor recreation opportunities and abundant wildlife resources. With the growth that shows no sign of slowing, will come development. But the tough decisions made today – decisions on where and how that development occurs – will have far-reaching, permanent impacts on the wildlife and wild lands that – at least in part – are responsible for that growth.

These are tough decisions. They are especially tough here in the west where, for decades, economies have been driven by natural resource utilization; where private property rights reign, including a landowner’s right to develop their land.

But communities, through their elected officials, have a responsibility to shape their own future form through planning and zoning decisions. And individuals have a right, and an obligation, to weigh in and let their opinions be heard on these tough decisions that affect the public’s wildlife and wild lands.

A string of tough decisions punctuate our state’s past, with history being the final judge of whether they were the right decisions. Almost a century ago, Boise River waters were captured by Arrowrock Dam and delivered to surrounding land to make the Treasure Valley green. History has not questioned that decision. In the middle of the last century, the Snake River was dammed in Hells Canyon to provide cheap and abundant electricity. A cost was the permanent loss of salmon runs above there. More recently, Interstate 84, was built from Burley to Salt Lake, bisecting a key mule deer migration and winter range area to improve travel to Salt Lake City and beyond. A cost was the permanent reduction of 15,000 mule deer.

While historians may continue to debate decisions of the past other tough decisions arrive at our doorstep.

Key among those facing the Treasure Valley are where new homes, new neighborhoods, new restaurants and stores will be built to accommodate future growth. Will development continue to occur in the valley, gobbling up wheat and alfalfa fields? Will it set its sights on the arid desert to the south and east? Or will it creep further into the foothills – foothills that are critical winter range for deer and elk that during the rest of the year provide wildlife viewing enjoyment and hunting opportunity over a large expanse of Southwest Idaho; foothills where countless valley residents recreate and frequently fix their gaze just to feel they are in Idaho?

Developments currently being considered call for large tracts of the foothills to be developed into planned communities. Today’s tough decisions on whether or not to change current zoning to accomodate such planned communities or high density development in the foothills will have lasting affects on wildlife. It could be a premier place to live, but would history judge the cost in premier wildlife and wildlife habitat to be too great?

Be a part of history. Take time to learn about the implications of upcoming development proposals and then ask yourself, do they represent progress? Ada County decision makers will be holding public hearings beginning in September for the first of several large foothills development proposals. Weigh in. Be a part of the tough decisions.

Comments & Discussion

Comments are closed for this post.

  1. A Very Concerned Citizen
    Aug 7, 2005, 10:45 pm

    Just a note to all those great hard working citizens working on the project to save the Plateau – – based on the reception that other neighborhoods are getting from the Boise Planning and Zoning Commission and the Boise Planning Staff – let us save you a lot of work…..they don’t care about your view….and regardless of what evidence you present they will not listen or consider it. They work FOR the developers NOT the citizens. You need to understand that they are against you even before you start. Sorry to be the bearer of the bad news.

  2. While eloquently written, I can hardly accept the comparison between building a dam on the Snake and building a necessary commerce route between Idaho and Salt Lake to a private housing development aimed at having houses with a good view, for more than likely quite a bit of profit.

    There is plenty of available land out there for planned communities and lots of open spaces that will have less of an affect on local wildlife than the Hammer Flats development. But alas, they won’t have the view, hence the profit, the seemingly ambiguous motivation around most of Idaho’s current development and growth.

Get the Guardian by email

Enter your email address: