Question: Shall the City of Boise City, Idaho protect clean water and drinking water, wildlife habitat, critical open space, and native plant species, and enhance recreation opportunities and trails through the establishment of a fund from a temporary override levy enabling the purchase of property and improvement projects in areas such as the Boise Foothills and the Boise River? All levy funds must be spent solely on the benefits listed above, not administrative costs, and the fund will be subject to review by a citizens’ advisory committee and an annual audit. The levy will raise the amount of five million dollars each year for two years commencing with the fiscal year beginning October 1, 2016 and ending September 30, 2018.
CONSIDER THESE POINTS:
–Nothing in the language would prohibit making payments to United Water to “protect drinking water.”
–While the EPA, Idaho Water Resources, and DEQ are charged with administering “clean water,” the mayor and council could claim citizens approved a levy to allow them to act.
–Same is true for wildlife and plants. In fact, Boise purchased Hammer Flat east of town, promptly closed it to all public access for “plant and wildlife inventory.” The secret action (secret land acquisition is legal) was nothing more than a deal to use the Foothills Levy as a finance mechanism for the State of Idaho which eventually purchased the land.
The GUARDIAN has received several letters from Foothills users and conservationists. The one below is most revealing in that Team Dave attempted to use the Foothills Conservation Advisory Committee for political gain. The group no longer exists–despite a previous ballot provision and ordinance. The mayor’s office now makes the spending decisions once reserved for citizens.
FROM A FOOTHILLS ADVOCATE
On May 22, 2001, 59% of Boise voters supported a two-year serial levy (2002 and 2003) in order to raise $10 million for Foothills land preservation efforts. According to the official ballot language (see attachment), the funds would be subject to review by a citizens committee and an annual independent audit.
Shortly after the passage of the Foothills Levy, the Mayor and the City Council approved the creation of the Foothills Conservation Advisory Committee (Chapter 2-23 of Boise Municipal Code see attachment) to “…make recommendations to the Mayor and City Council for permanent protection of natural open space in the Boise foothills, consistent with the open space serial levy passed by the voters on May 22, 2001, and will work to ensure that the levy funds are spent wisely.”
Many of the original twelve members of the Foothills Conservation Advisory Committee (FCAC) were citizens that had worked tirelessly to organize the grassroots Foothills Levy efforts – making phone calls, knocking on doors, tabling at community event, fundraising for the campaign, etc…
The language in the Code said the FCAC would sunset in 2008 if all the funds were expended. When 2008 rolled around there was still over $4 million left in the fund, so the City Council did a one year extension on the FCAC followed by a few other 6 month and 3 month extensions. The last extension ran out in September 2012. While the Foothills Conservation Advisory Committee is no longer, the City of Boise website would lead the public to believe that the committee still exists http://mayor.cityofboise.org/boards-and-commissions/foothills-conservation-advisory-committee/ SEE THIS
In September 2012 the levy had been replenished from the sale of Hammer Flat to Idaho Fish and Game (July 2012), so there was about $4.3 million in the levy. The 154 acre N. Collister piece was purchased in December 2012 for $500K and then 260 acre Hillside to Hollow parcel purchased in May 2013 for $1.9 million (the FCAC is mentioned in that press release by the city as quoted by Jon Kaji of the sellers Boise Foothills TIC and then again at the bottom about the property being a priority of the FCAC). http://mayor.cityofboise.org/news-releases/2013/04/city-to-consider-purchase-of-hillside-to-the-hollow-foothills-property/ CITY RELEASE
In the Fall 2013, the mayor called all the previous FCAC members together for a meeting at the Foothills Learning Center. It was not a celebration of how we had stretched the initial $10 million to protect over $30 million worth of public open space in the Boise foothills, it was to ask us to be advocates on behalf of the $34 million parks and fire bond he wanted to pass in November.
During that meeting he said he would reinstate the FCAC if the bond passed. The bond failed that November and the FCAC was not reinstated. While I don’t have the most current figures, I do know that as of March 31, 2015, there was still $1.5 million in the Foothills Levy Fund, the City owns close to 4,000 acres of foothills Reserves. Since 2015, the city has acquired additional land.
I sat on the Open Space Matters planning committee in 2014 and asked City Parks Director Doug Holloway about the 2001 foothills levy language which involved the development of a citizen’s committee and annual audits.
I specifically asked Mr. Holloway how the city was in compliance with the language of the 2001 levy. Currently the City Council and Mayor are calling the shots without any input by a citizen’s committee on land acquisition. According to Mr. Holloway, the city’s legal department said that is fine. Personally, I find this concerning.
Here we are less than a month away from a second foothills levy which includes the same exact language indicating the “levy will be subject to both a citizen’s advisory committee and annual audits” yet if we look at what has happened with the 2001 levy the city has not been very transparent.
In addition, there is nothing that has been presented to the public to reassure us that the city (mayor/city council) will be transparent in their open space acquisition dealings. To be honest with you if the general public knew what has gone on the last three years, then folks would be asking the same question I’m asking where is the transparency?
To insure more advertising-free Boise Guardian news, please consider financial support.